Oh I know, lots of knitters just looove knitting socks. I’ve knit a whole lot myself, but I definitely have a love/hate thing going with them.
The pros:
They’re generally straight-forward. There are some wildly complex patterns, but most socks have a fair bit of easy knitting combined with some interesting bits.
They’re almost a sure-thing gift. If the recipient doesn’t care for the color or style, they’re socks. They can still easily get use out of them, even if it’s just slouching around the house or wearing while walking the dog.
They’re a sure-thing for yourself. As long as you get even vaguely close in size, this is something you will definitely be able to wear. Not like that bulky-weight novelty yarn sweater you have stashed in your closet that you admire sometimes but only actually wear once or twice. Or the sweater that you ended up getting rid of so you wouldn’t have to keep feeling guilty that you never wear it (and it didn’t fit right anyway). Or the lovely wrap that you don’t use because wraps can be such a hassle. Etc.
Fine gauge means more knitting for your money. Generally, you get more knitting time out of finer gauges of yarn, and projects often cost less.
The cons:
They’re socks. Which will typically be covered up by shoes and pant legs, making it tough to show them off. It’s really not common that anyone is going to say, “Oh wow, look at those socks you’re wearing, did you knit those yourself?!” Come on, you know you want that to happen when you wear your own knits, admit it!
You have to make two of them. Which can be soooo tedious! Oh sure, you could use double-knitting to knit two at once on the same needles. Ha! It ain’t the fastest method, since you have to move both yarns back and forth between the needles for every single stitch—not too bad for some things, but socks tend to use a finer gauge and take long enough as it is. Using a method that makes it even slower doesn’t seem like the best solution to me. And god forbid you twist the yarns on accident, there is no way to fix that except to rip back to the point where they’re twisted; unlike a double-knit hat or scarf the socks will be absolutely useless if they’re joined together, so you have no option but to rip back, you can’t just let that one go or duplicate stitch over it to hide it. IMO, the best way to avoid second-sock syndrome is to knit both at the same time on two sets of needles, it’s faster than double-knitting and it ensures they’ll be just the same and finished at close to the same time. But still, tedious.
Fine gauge means they take a long time. Fine gauge has its own pros and cons, it costs less, but it takes longer. If you knit a lot, no problem, but if you don’t get in a lot of knitting time you may not want to spend your precious few hours on socks. You can use a heavier gauge and knit heavier socks, but you might get less practical use out of those (though if you like really heavy boot socks and wear them often, you’re in luck).
You’d better get the gauge exactly right. As they’re so small, fit is probably more crucial and exacting on socks than just about anything else you could knit. So you’d better swatch well. And you’d better be knitting at the same tension the entire time, too, if you relax more with the second sock you might well end up with a slight bit looser tension resulting in a larger sock.
And finally…
THEY’RE SOCKS! Seriously, what’s with the sock obsession? There are so many books devoted to them, websites, Knitty puts out several sock patterns in every issue, for crying outloud. Srly, you guys; you guys, srly.
Now someone come and club me over the head before I actually cast on these funky-fitted socks from Knitty. This was actually what spurred this entire rant, I know I’m going to end up starting them, and I’m going to hate them while I’m knitting them, too. Damn you, Knitty! [shakes tiny fist]
But hey, I can always find a use for them once they’re finished, right?
